The World Bank Group (WBG) Independent Evaluation Group (IEG) has released two new evaluations of WBG safeguards performance: one assesses the implementation of IFC’s Sustainability Framework (SF) from 2012-2025, and the other examines the World Bank’s Environmental and Social Framework (ESF) from 2019-2025. These reports come as the WBG undertakes a major restructuring process that aims to better harmonize its public and private sector work. At the same time, the institution, namely the International Finance Corporation (IFC), is undertaking its first review of the Sustainability Framework in over a decade. The evaluations are therefore well timed to inform these policy and structural changes, but their value will depend on whether management acts on the recommendations and addresses the weaknesses identified in environmental and social safeguards implementation.
The evaluations echo a number of issues that BIC has raised previously in our project monitoring and policy advocacy. A common theme in both reports is the need for strong systems to incentivize and resource safeguards implementation; policies are only as strong as an institution’s commitment to implementing them, as well as the infrastructure in place to support their full and consistent application. The SF evaluation highlights implementation gaps across several Performance Standards and in the application of the Access to Information Policy. One of the four recommendations of the IFC evaluation is focused on strengthening implementation.
Addressing Gaps in Social Risk Management
Both evaluations examine how institutions address social issues in policy and practice, including risks to marginalized groups, and the prevention of sexual exploitation, abuse, and harassment (SEA/H). While the World Bank has strengthened its policy requirements and guidance in these areas, IEG’s ESF evaluation finds that these commitments have not consistently translated into practice. For example, although the Bank has made clear commitments to universal accessibility in its projects, gaps in data on persons with disabilities make it difficult to assess whether they are actually benefiting from and accessing the services from project investments. Furthermore, our project monitoring establishes that persons with disabilities experience distinct barriers and harms that must be addressed, including increased susceptibility to climate-related events.
On the private sector side, IEG points to the management of social risks and impacts, including SEA/H, as a significant policy gap that IFC should address in its SF review. BIC has also called on IFC to strengthen protections against child SEA/H in the updated Performance Standards. The review offers an opportunity to address these gaps through clearer requirements, stronger risk assessment, and supportive implementation measures.
Strengthening Stakeholder Engagement
Both evaluations consider how the institutions incorporate views and concerns of project stakeholders through consultation and grievance redress mechanisms (GRM). The ESF evaluation finds that the introduction of Environmental and Social Standard 10 (ESS10), which covers stakeholder engagement and information disclosure, led to the development of stakeholder engagement plans and grievance mechanisms for nearly all Bank-financed projects. The Bank needs to improve its documentation of whether and/or how effective GRMs are in receiving and resolving grievances, and how project teams use stakeholder input to course correct in the adaptive management of its projects.
In the private sector, IEG identifies a significant policy gap compared to peer institutions, and recommends that IFC develop a specific policy on stakeholder engagement that incorporates existing guidance, including on preventing and responding to reprisals. IFC has indicated it will create a standalone stakeholder engagement standard, offering an opportunity to incorporate these recommendations and strengthen protections for stakeholders.
Holding Management Accountable
In its response to the two IEG reports, WBG management noted its acceptance and agreement with the findings, and committed to implementing the recommendations. WBG Board members should take this commitment seriously and hold management accountable for providing updates on the concrete steps it is taking to address gaps and weaknesses. As the WBG continues to harmonize its public and private sectors, it must apply lessons learned from the public sector rather than risk weakening existing safeguards.
The World Bank Group should continue to build staff and borrower capacity in areas such as SEA/H prevention, stakeholder engagement, and disability inclusion to turn policy into meaningful practice on the ground. As IFC prepares to release the first draft of its updated Sustainability Framework, it should critically assess and act upon the institutional incentives, culture, resources, and leverage needed to improve safeguards implementation and performance.
Note: BIC served as a peer reviewer for the IEG’s ESF evaluation and participated in consultations with IEG staff around both reports.